Six Nations Round 3: Three Things We Learned

Round three of the 2025 Guinness Six Nations marked the true turning point in this year’s competition, separating the genuine title contenders from the chasing pack. With the tournament now past its halfway stage, the weekend’s action provided much-needed clarity.

Ireland, the reigning champions, continued their winning streak, England secured a hard-fought victory over Scotland, and France responded emphatically to their previous defeat. Here’s a deeper dive into the key talking points:

1. Refereeing Ruckus: Consistency and Clarity Demanded

The spotlight on officiating intensified following a series of contentious decisions. England’s victory over Scotland was marred by disputed calls, including Tommy Freeman’s try and Maro Itoje’s turnover, both of which ignited furious discussions about interpretations of the laws.

The over-reliance on the TMO also drew criticism, with many arguing that the constant stoppages are disrupting the flow of the game and diminishing the spectacle. A call for greater consistency and a more judicious use of the TMO is growing louder, with many suggesting a focus on clear and obvious errors, particularly in scoring plays and dangerous play, only when the referee actively requests it.

2. A Two-Horse Race? The Championship Picture Emerges

The tournament has begun to reveal a clear division, with Ireland and France establishing themselves as the frontrunners. Their upcoming clash at the Aviva Stadium is set to be a titanic encounter, potentially deciding the fate of the championship.

While England remains mathematically in contention, their victory over France was somewhat flattered by French errors, raising questions about their consistency. Wales and Scotland, despite moments of brilliance, continue to struggle for consistency, battling for positions within the chasing pack. England appears to be building a solid foundation, but Ireland and France have established a formidable lead.

3. Fly-Half Frenzy: The Lions Loom Large

The race for the coveted British & Irish Lions fly-half jersey is heating up, with Finn Russell and Marcus Smith facing mounting pressure. Finn Russell’s inconsistency in crucial moments, highlighted by missed conversions against England, has raised concerns. Conversely, Marcus Smith has seen his starting role usurped by Finn Smith, whose composed performances have impressed observers.

Finn Smith’s rise provides a compelling narrative, his maturity at a young age being a huge positive. Ireland’s Jack Crowley remains a dark horse, his potential to influence big games undeniable. A standout performance against France could propel him back into the Lions conversation. The remaining rounds will be pivotal in determining who emerges as the frontrunner.

With only two rounds remaining, the 2025 Six Nations is poised for a thrilling climax. Expect fireworks as the Six Nations drama intensifies!